Exit Strategies for Assets Held in a Self-Directed IRA

Published on October 20, 2026

Investors who plan to include alternative assets within their SDIRA are wise to develop an exit plan when the retirement plan makes the investment. Unlike publicly traded stocks and bonds, alternative assets held in a self-directed IRA are generally less liquid and may be difficult to value. And, depending on the asset, there may be transfer restrictions involved and there are always IRS compliance and delivery guidelines to follow.

Factors that influence the investor’s exit strategy

The exit strategy  will differ according to the asset, be it real estate, precious metals, commodities, secured and unsecured loans, tax liens, etc. as well as its performance in terms of appreciation, cash flow, and/or operating expenses. Factors include:

Examples of exit strategies for alternative assets within a self-directed IRA

            1) Sell the asset and reinvest in the IRA

This is the simplest route for investors who wish to reduce risk, meet distributions, or reposition their retirement capital.

Let’s say the SDIRA owns a piece of vacation property and you wish to sell the property. Since your IRA owns the property, all proceeds from its sale must go straight back into the IRA and NOT into your personal bank account, which would constitute self-dealing, a prohibited transaction. When the property sells at a profit, that gain stays within the SDIRA and increases its cash balance that can be reinvested.

If you are over the age of 59½ and eligible to take qualified distributions from the account, you can avoid penalties. The gains from a Traditional IRA, which were tax-deferred, will trigger a taxable event.

Keeping growth potential inside the self-directed IRA avoids large taxable events and continues to build up one’s retirement savings until the investor can take qualified cash distributions (or RMDs upon reaching age 73). Inside a Roth SDIRA, the gain is permanently tax-free if the account meets qualified distribution requirements.

            2) Take an in-kind distribution

In this scenario, the SDIRA custodian transfers the asset directly to you, in your name. An in-kind distribution may be done if you want to take personal control of an asset to manage, refinance, or sell it outside of the IRA’s framework. You can also distribute a percentage of the asset (a partial-interest in-kind transfer) to satisfy a specific financial obligation.

Be aware that the asset’s entire fair market value (FMV) will be treated as a taxable distribution from a Traditional, SIMPLE or SEP IRA, so the account owner must be prepared to cover that tax bill. A formal, good-faith fair market valuation of the alternative asset as of the date of the distribution (and reported on Form 1099-R) is required. With a Roth IRA, the in-kind property can be withdrawn tax-free when it is a qualified withdrawal (the investor is over 59½ and the account has been open for at least five years).

            3) Take cash distributions over time

The asset is sold within the SDIRA  and the investor can then spread the income over years with periodic distributions, minimizing the tax impact. This strategy also helps manage RMD planning.

            4) Convert the asset to a Roth IRA

This exit plan is generally used for assets that are expected to appreciate significantly. Although the Roth conversion requires paying taxes on the asset’s FMV, the future account growth and distributions will be tax-free.

            5) Negotiate a secondary sale or redemption

In the case of private equity, private placements, royalties, and partnership interests, the investor can seek a third-party buyer (secondary sale to an outside investor), sponsor repurchase, or contractual redemption with the original issuer or fund manager. These can be complicated arrangements, are regulated by the fund’s by-laws, and carry different tax considerations.

Make exit strategies part of your due diligence

Self-directed investors are expected to conduct full due diligence about their investments before sending instructions to the SDIRA custodian. Considering an exit strategy for each asset type can be part of that process…and should be revisited periodically as market conditions and asset performance change over time.

At Next Generation Trust Company, we strongly recommend our clients consult trusted advisors about how the alternative assets they invest in align with their retirement goals and their overall tax picture. If you have questions about self-direction as a retirement wealth-building strategy in general, or about specific assets allowed in SDIRAs, contact our team at 888.857.8058 or NewAccounts@NextGenerationTrust.com.

Back to Blog